The guys take on Mike's pick this week as they head to a town in West Virginia called.... Silent Hill. Welcome... to Hell!

Legendary blood donor Dana Tucker finds the guys in a tale of an intoxicated bear that goes on a rampage thanks to a little booger sugar. Join us for the 2023 Cocaine Bear.."Get in line!"

The guys find themselves in Brooklyn and in the middle of a full on vampire movie. Join us for 1995's Eddie Murphy and Wes Cravel-led.. Vampire in Brooklyn. A tale of horror and seduction!

The guys have really messed up this time. After breaking the mysterious "One Wish Willow", they find themselves getting... exactly what they wished for. Join us for 2026's Obsession!

The guys time travel to 1984 to protect Sarah Connor in the movie that launched a franchise. Join us for 1984's The Terminator. We'll Be Back!

It's Dustin's birthday, so join us for a fun bonus episode, as the guys discuss which horror movie universes they'd most like to live in!

The guys see a comet crash outside their sleepy small town and discover a pack of murderous alien circus clowns! Join us for 1988's Killer Klowns!

The guys are taking on running a tropical island resort as an unknown killer begins slaughtering the staff. Join us for 2004's Club Dread! A vacation to die for!

The guys are back and this week they are racing against time as a shark-obsessed serial killer holds them captive on his boat! You're safer in the water!

The guys are fending off the waters of a hurricane and something much more sinister lurking in the water as they take on 2019's Crawl! They were here first!

After witnessing the execution of serial killer Edgar Reese, the guys take on another case that has a very similar feel! Join us for 1998's Fallen! Don't trust a soul!

The year is halfway gone, so Nicoh and Dustin are handing out some awards for the first half!

The latest in the British "Twisted Childhood Universe" brings us to a retelling of the story of Wendy Darling and her attempt to rescue her brother from the clutches of the evil Peter Pan. Join us for 2025's Peter Pan's Neverland Nightmare. He's every parents' worst nightmare.

Join the guys as they tackle 2024's Curry Barker directorial debut, Milk and Serial. When a viral prank becomes a nightmare!

We are moving into remake territory as the guys take on the 2019 Aubrey Plaza-led remake of Child's Play! Time to play!

A social media moderator is tasked with purging the most offensive content from the internet and of course she calls Nicoh, Mike and Dustin when she sees a video that appears to show a crime. Murder is never out of style!

The guys are on Elm Street once again as they take on the fifth installment of the legendary franchise. Join us as we delve into A Nightmare on Elm Street 5, The Dream Child. It's time for Freddy.. to deliver.

The guys have once again become a victim of a middle-aged woman and terror ensues as they party in her basement. Join us for the 2019 Octavia Spencer-led "Ma." Get Home Safe!

They guys have been kidnapped by two conspiracy-obsessed men as theyre convinced she's an alien who wants to destroy earth! Join us for the 2025 Emma Stone-led.. Bugonia. It all starts with something magnificent!

The fan votes are in and you chose the 1976 classic, Sissy Spacek-led Carrie! Join us as we head back to high school for some strange occurrences in this chilling adaption of Stephen King's horror novel. You were warned never to push Carrie to the limits, now you must face the consequences!